SPR says yes to indelible ink for elections

To use indelible ink is one of the three demands presented by BERSIH last year. The other two demands are abolishment of postal votes (except for citizens living overseas) and clean up the current electoral rolls.

DAP and BERSIH will continue to press for greater electoral reforms for a fair, clean and transparent elections.

 EC’s ‘aye’ to use of indelible ink

Beh Lih Yi
Jun 1, 07 6:20pm
Malaysiakini 

The Election Commission (EC) has finally given the nod to the use of indelible ink in elections to prevent multiple voting, a proposal long demanded by the opposition and election watchdogs.

“In principle, yes, the commission has agreed to the proposal pending further research on two issues,” EC chairperson Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman told malaysiakini this afternoon.

The two issues are whether there is a need to amend the relevant legislation such as the Election (Conduct of Elections) Regulations 1981 and the material (ink) to be used in implementing the proposal.

“We hope we can carry out the proposal in time for the forthcoming general election because there have been a lot of requests on this, especially from the opposition.

“Although the reason they used (to call for indelible ink) was very weak as the alleged electoral fraud was not proven in court, we still agree to do this to satisfy them,” said Rashid.

Thumbprint, biometric system

Rashid’s statement today came six months after he reportedly shot down the idea of using indelible ink on the ground that the method was ‘archaic’.

However, he explained today that he had never rejected the idea but only said the proposal needed to be further discussed with commission members.

Elaborating, the EC chief said the green light to use indelible ink was reached at a recent meeting in Penang attended by commission members and state EC chiefs after having deliberated at length on other methods to prevent multiple voting.

Other methods that were discussed include identification of thumbprint and the use of biometric system but Rashid said the EC concluded that using indelible ink is the “cheapest and easiest” way.

“The biometric system is estimated to cost RM30 million and it will only be used every five years and maybe we have to change the system sometime later, while using thumbprint may not be easy as it is difficult to detect the thumbprint if your hand is dirty,” he explained.

On the contrary, he said indelible ink has been widely used in other countries.

“But we have to find out what kind of product will be the most reliable that we should use, otherwise it may bring more problems,” Rashid pointed out in reference to poor quality of ink that may render the method ineffective.

On the possibility to amend the Act, the EC chief said he has instructed the commission’s legal advisor to study the matter.

“If the need to amend the law arises, then it will takes time (to implement the proposal). If we can, we will do it in the coming general election, otherwise it will be later,” he replied.

Two-hour meeting with DAP

The EC’s agreement on the use of indelible ink was first conveyed to a DAP delegation during a two-hour meeting held at the commission’s headquarters in Putrajaya this morning.

The delegation was headed by DAP secretary-general Lim Guan Eng. Others present were the party’s parliamentarians Teresa Kok, Tan Kok Wai and Fong Kui Lun.

Welcoming the EC’s endorsement on the use of indelible ink, Lim said Rashid has also assured that the transparent ballot boxes – a proposal adopted by the EC earlier – will continue to be used in the coming elections.

Contacted by malaysiakini after the meeting, Lim also quoted Rashid as agreeing for an oversight mechanism on the postal voting process but said the jurisdiction to implement the mechanism “is beyond EC”.

“We counter propose that interim measures can be carried out such as allowing polling agents to monitor and observe the whole process.

“Such monitoring has been rejected so far on the ground of security (in army bases) but we can see kacang putih or mi rebus sellers going in,” argued Lim.

During the meeting, the DAP also submitted a three-page memorandum to Rashid calling for 10 areas of reforms (see chart below) in the electoral system to be done before the EC chief’s retirement at the end of this year.

“The time has come for Rashid to leave behind his legacy of removing electoral roll irregularities, enforcing the Election Offences Act 1954 and using indelible ink towards establishing a clean, free, fair and impartial elections,” said Lim in the memorandum.

Opposition and election watchdogs have been pushing for the use of indelible ink especially in the wake of a series of electoral irregularities reported in the recent Ijok by-election.

Kelantan PAS leader Husam Musa had, in a recent interview, also stressed on the need to use indelible ink, failing which he expressed fears the Islamic party may lose Kelantan in the coming general election.

3 Responses to “SPR says yes to indelible ink for elections”

  1. KSTAN Says:

    NGOs and the opposition parties must continue to pressure SPR to get their act together. While Rashid’s recent annoucements are good and well, we must make sure that SPR updates the electoral roll and take out those fake names and dead voters.

  2. sampalee Says:

    To those who draws comfort from the indelible ink.The master of fake democracy have already have a special removing solution that was privy only to these cheats.Science can be use for good and bad. Fear of god is the ONLY safeguard.Put religion back into public life and not something personal.Truth as revealed by all religion is NEVER personal[unlike concepts of man,such as democracy,secularism.communism,capitalist,socialism.feudalism,dictatorship and the whole host of personal believe]

  3. ronnieliutiankhiew Says:

    Use of indelible ink a ‘backward’ step

    New Straits Times

    The move to use indelible ink on the thumb of voters to safeguard against multiple or phantom voting has been described as a regressive step.

    Gerakan secretary-general Datuk Seri Chia Kwang Chye said the Election Commission proposal was an outdated method and it should be dropped.

    “I consider this as taking a step backward. I believe the EC should have cleaned the electoral roll by now and got rid of all phantom members.

    “It comes as a surprise that they are considering introducing the use of indelible ink.”

    He was commenting on EC chairman Tan Sri Abdul Rashid Abdul Rahman’s statement on Friday that the commission would use indelible ink on the thumbs of those who cast their ballots at the next general election.

    Abdul Rashid said this would prevent the voters from voting a second time. Chia said the EC must have confidence in doing a fair job.

    “They had done a fair and efficient job in the last general election. What’s important now is that they should move forward and improve the process instead of regressing to an old system,” said Chia after announcing that the Bukit Bendera Family Day would be held this Sunday.

    The event is being organised by the Bukit Bendera MP and the state assemblymen for Tanjung Bunga, Kebung Bunga, Pulau Tikus and Air Putih.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: